Longtime sellers are closing their Etsy shops rather than let their work train artificial intelligence. The Etsy AI training terms take effect on December 16, and the new language gives Etsy and its partners a broad license to use seller content to develop AI systems. For artists who built their livelihoods on the marketplace, that was the final straw.

The Etsy logo. Image: Etsy
What the new terms say
Etsy published revised Terms of Use on October 26, and the changes take effect on December 16. The new language says Etsy and its “third party partners and vendors” reserve the right to use sellers’ content to “develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies”. The previous version of the terms did not include any clause about using content for AI.
There is no simple way to refuse. Sellers cannot switch off AI training in their account settings. Instead, they must email Etsy’s data protection officer and ask for their data not to be used, according to Cybernews, which reported that some sellers who contacted the company were told to close their accounts if they disagreed with the terms.
Sellers are leaving before the holidays
Artists are shutting down their shops and posting illustrated goodbye notes to tell customers where to find them next, Cartoon Brew reported. Closing a shop just weeks before the holidays means giving up potential seasonal sales, years of reviews, and a storefront customers already know how to find.
Aaron Millard, an illustrator, said he was deleting the shop he has run for nearly a decade. “Etsy decided that selling on their platform now means letting them train AI on our artwork AND resell that data to third parties, with no way to opt out,” he wrote in an Instagram post. “My work took years to learn and create. I won’t let it be stolen.”
Kristen and Geoff Zephyrus, founders of the home goods and stationery brand Cognitive Surplus, which has sold on Etsy for 13 years, also deleted their shop. They accused the company of claiming “perpetual, free, boundless permission to not only train AI on our art, but also to resell the data for profit.” “For Etsy to be helping to train algorithms with our human content is just unimaginably awful,” Kristen Zephyrus said in an interview. “We don’t want anything to do with that.”
War and Peas, a shop selling prints, books and apparel, also closed its Etsy store. “You might have heard of Etsy’s new terms and artists fleeing the platform. We’re out, too,” the business wrote on X. No one has published a reliable count of how many sellers have left because of the changes.

Handmade beaded jewelry at a market stall. Image: Agness Abubakar Saidi / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)
What Etsy says
In a statement posted to Etsy’s website on Monday, November 16, James Ossman, the company’s vice president for customer operations, told sellers that Etsy will not “use your content to train A.I. models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity.” He cited fraud detection tools and advertisements on the site as reasons for granting third parties access to sellers’ content. Etsy says it uses seller content to spot fraud and help shoppers find products.
That assurance has not calmed the sellers who are leaving. The terms themselves are broad, and as Cartoon Brew noted, the vague language leaves open just how Etsy’s partners and vendors might use the same content. A representative for Etsy did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Friday, the New York Times reported.
The irony, and the wider backlash
The timing adds to the anger. Just weeks earlier, Etsy announced tighter rules on misleading AI product photos and bot-generated listings, after users complained about so-called AI slop flooding the marketplace. Etsy still allows sellers to list work generated from their own prompts, as long as they disclose the use of AI to buyers. Sellers see a double standard: the platform tells them not to use AI to generate listings, yet reserves the right to use their content to train its own AI.
Etsy, founded in 2005 to help independent artisans find customers online, is no stranger to user revolt. In 2022, more than 20,000 sellers went on strike to protest a fee increase that lifted its base sales fee to 6.5 percent from 5 percent. The company is also caught in a wider mood: a Gallup poll from the summer found that nearly 40 percent of Americans feel that AI does more harm than good.
Why it matters
Etsy built its brand on the idea that a real person made the thing you are buying. If the makers who give the marketplace its identity keep walking away, that promise weakens, and so does the reason shoppers choose Etsy over any other store. The December 16 deadline, landing in the middle of the Christmas shopping season, forces sellers to choose between their busiest weeks and terms they fundamentally oppose.
The practical question now is whether Etsy narrows the license, clarifies what its partners may do, or adds a real opt-out before the terms take effect. Until then, the goodbye notes keep coming, and each one points customers somewhere else.
Sources
- The New York Times: Many Etsy Sellers Close Up Shop Over Site’s New A.I. Policy (full text via DNYUZ)
- Cartoon Brew: Artists Leave Etsy In Droves Over New AI Training Terms
- Cybernews: Etsy AI training terms spark seller backlash
- Crypto Briefing: Etsy sellers close shops over AI policy taking effect December 16

